Posted by: thirdculturemom | February 2, 2008

Education–I think

Kalessin is doing The Canterbury Tales in “core class”. He wrote a required five paragraph essay about his favorite tale, the Pardoner’s Tale. I noticed the following paragraph in it:

The second reason I like this story is because it is funny. While it may seem sad that the friends died because of their greed, since this is fictional, I find it humorous. Another thing that makes me laugh is that they try to “find” death, but in turn death finds them. These things all seem to be funny to me. I’m sorry if my humor is a bit dark.

I am just reading Stephen King’s On Writing, in which he mentions having to explain to readers who accuse him of cruelty to animals because of something that a character in a book does to a dog that the character wasn’t real, and the dog never existed. In other word’s, it’s fiction. Kalessin seems to get this.

So maybe kids are learning something in school these days….

Not as much as they would want to, though–the kid complained that even though there are twenty-something Canterbury tales, they only let them read (in modern adaptation, of course) four, because the others are not appropriate for children. “Dude, that sucks. I want to read the others,” he says. “And like we already know all that bad stuff anyway. You should hear what people are talking about at lunch.”


Responses

  1. “Dude, that sucks.”

    I had to laugh at that. I really need to learn to start saying “dude” more. I’m so uncool.

  2. A sense of irony and the desire to know the rest of the story. There is hope for the future after all.

  3. I like it that he found it necessary to so carefully explain that he thought it was funny because it was fictional.

    Frankly, I’d find it funny if some of my real-life acquaintances were tracked down by Death due to their greediness.

  4. Dude is the least they call each other at that middle school, Ina. You probably don’t want to be as cool as some of them….

    Irony he’s got tons of, Ivy–if there’s a recipe to convert just a little bit of the excess into other areas, I would love to have it. (I won’t even say into him tidying his room–if he just knew where his stuff is, I’d be happy.)

    David, I think he entertains similar thoughts sometimes, but perhaps he didn’t want the teacher to think he was evil. (Evil is a word that comes up a lot when discussing teachers.)

  5. I think it’s awesome that they have introduced The Canterbury Tales in school. Hide The Decameron, though.

    So often, it seems, my sons were handed newer books, and it was their subversive mother handing them Gilgamesh and Beowulf (and Grendel) and even — believe it or not — Animal Farm. I was astonished to learn they no longer had kids reading Orwell’s books.

    On the other hand, the entire reading list for 9th grade English was a lesson in ways to die.

  6. I meant to say “they have been introduced to” … in that first sentence. So much for editing as I go.

  7. Wow. I still haven’t read that one.

  8. The choices are unpredictable, but that’s not necessarily bad. Another thing they’ve just read is The Great Train Robbery by Crichton.

  9. My 17 y/o read Animal Farm, 1984, The Great Gatsby, Canterbury Tales, and a lot of the stuff I had to read in high school. It was nice because it reminded me of wonderful books I had forgotten so I picked them up and re-read them when she was reading them. It gave us things to discuss. Oh, and it made mom look cool and smart because she could answer the questions her daughter had! A definite plus!

  10. I remember reading those in high school. Sigh… those were the days.

  11. Oh oh oh! That is beautiful.

    The day before yesterday, my youngest explained something similar. After explaining a big long thing that involved some implausibilities and having those implausibilities pointed out, the child responded, “It’s fictional.” in just the tone of voice that made me laugh.

  12. I am ashamed to admit I have never read Canterbury Tales. I’ll make it a 2008 project.

    What do you think of On Writing? I liked the autobiography of Mr. King: The story behind the stories.

  13. I know I’ve read that CT’s, but it is a blur. A mom of ten grown children whose husband is long gone gifted me a ton of books. (Several years ago she downsized houses and realized she didn’t have room.) Many of these were assigned reading books. The funnest thing is her kids left a lot of really funny notes and comments in the margins. What’s even funnier is that a couple if these kids are my friends. I laugh to myself sometimes when I read the snarky comments they made as teens.

  14. Marilee! You’re here too. And it looks like I haven’t been here for two months….


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories